E-1 evidence

Substantial Trade and the 50 Percent Rule: Proving Your E-1 Case

Two tests decide every E-1 application. Is there enough trade? And is most of it with the United States? Both are answered with spreadsheets and shipping papers, not with promises.

Book my 30-minute E-1 consultation for $50

Updated November 2026

NoneMinimum dollar volume fixed by law
More than 50%Share of international trade with the U.S.
A continuous flowWhat officers want to see
  • $50 for a 30-minute consultation
  • Credited toward your fees
  • English & Fran√ßais
  • 10+ years in immigration law
  • Offices in the U.S. and Paris
  • U.S. and French immigration
  • Help in English and French

Test one: substantial trade

“Substantial” means a continuous flow of sizeable international trade items, with numerous transactions over time. A single large contract is not a flow. Officers consider:

Frequency

How many transactions, and how regularly.

Value

Total volume, with greater weight to larger transactions.

Continuity

Trade expected to keep going, shown by ongoing contracts and orders.

Income

For smaller firms, whether the trade is enough to support the trader and family.

Test two: principal trade

More than half of the trader’s international trade must be between the United States and the treaty country. Domestic sales do not enter the calculation.

Example companyTrade with the U.S.Other international tradeResult
French exporter A€600,000 France to U.S.€300,000 to other countries67%: passes
French exporter B€400,000 France to U.S.€900,000 to other countries31%: fails
French exporter C€250,000 France to U.S.None; €2 million sold in France100%: passes

Company C shows why the E-1 suits firms with a strong home market and one export destination.

Whose trade is measured?

The test applies to the trading entity in the United States. Where that entity is a branch, the whole company’s international trade is examined; where it is a separately incorporated subsidiary, the subsidiary’s own trade is what counts. Structure can therefore change the result, and it should be decided before you apply.

The documents that prove trade

  • A transaction ledger listing each shipment or invoice by date, amount and counterparty
  • Purchase orders, sales contracts and invoices
  • Bills of lading, airway bills and customs declarations
  • Wire transfers and bank statements matching the invoices
  • For services: contracts, statements of work, deliverables and proof of payment
  • Financial statements and tax returns for both sides

Bring us your last two years of export figures. We will run the E-1 tests with you.$50 for 30 minutes

Book for $50

Building the trade file

  1. Extract the data

    Export a list of all international transactions from your accounting system.

  2. Compute the ratio

    France to U.S. trade divided by total international trade, by value and by number.

  3. Select supporting papers

    A representative sample for each month, tied to bank records.

  4. Explain the business

    A short narrative on products, clients, logistics and expected growth.

  5. Plan for renewal

    Keep the ledger current so the next application takes days, not weeks.

Trade in services

Services qualify when a provider in one country delivers to a client in the other, and payment crosses the border. A French engineering firm billing U.S. clients, or a U.S. subsidiary buying design work from its French parent, can both generate E-1 trade. Keep contracts and deliverables, because there is no customs record to rely on.

Questions clients ask us

How many transactions do I need?

There is no fixed number. A steady series over at least several months, with contracts showing it will continue, is what persuades officers.

Does trade between my French company and its own U.S. subsidiary count?

Yes. Trade between related companies counts, provided it is real, documented and priced.

Can I qualify if trade has not started?

No. Trade must exist at the time of application. Binding contracts already being performed can be sufficient.

What if my U.S. share drops below 50 percent later?

E-1 eligibility ends. Monitor the ratio and prepare an alternative such as an E-2 or L-1 in advance.

Know where you stand in 30 minutes

One call with a U.S. and France immigration lawyer. You leave with a clear answer on eligibility, timing and cost.

  1. Book

    Pick a time that suits you and pay the $50 fee online.

  2. Meet

    Talk through your situation by video or phone, in English or French.

  3. Plan

    Get a clear route, a document list and a fee quote.

Book my 30-minute E-1 consultation for $50

The $50 fee is non-refundable and is deducted from your final legal fees if you retain our firm. Appointments can be rescheduled. Missed your appointment? Contact assistant@ariflawofficespc.com to reschedule.